Wilderness Land Trust
  • ABOUT
    • Our Mission
    • Our Story
    • Our Staff
    • Our Board
    • Join Our Team
    • Newsletters
    • Annual Reports & Financials
  • HOW WE WORK
    • Our Process
    • Stories
    • Landowners
    • Videos
    • Wilderness Book Club
  • NEWS
    • Recent News
    • Press
  • PROJECTS
    • Projects by State
  • GET INVOLVED
    • Donate
    • Ways to Give
    • Support a Project
  • CONTACT US
  • Donate Now
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu

What we can learn from the Roadless Rule public comments

October 30, 2026-

In August of this year, a forty-five day public comment period opened on the draft environmental impact statement for the Trump Administration’s proposed rule to rescind the 2001 Roadless Area Conservation Rule. Over 1 million people participated in the comment period, generating over 390,000 submissions and 81,000 unique comments. We can learn a lot from them: not only from the sheer volume of people who participated, but from what they had to say about our public lands and wild places.

Roadless.org, a coalition of conservation organizations, completed an in-depth analysis of the comments, finding that 97% of comments opposed rescission of the Roadless Rule, 2% supported rescission, and <1% were neutral or unclear. It’s worth noting that when the Roadless Rule was first proposed 25 years ago and a similar public comment period was held, about 95% of the 1.6 million comments supported the rule, suggesting that it has lived up to its original promise for many.

Statistically, the top five topics mentioned in comments were: environmental protection and biodiversity; recreation, tourism, and public use; water quality and quantity; wildlife habitat; and forest management and wildfire. None of those come as a surprise in arguments about the importance of protecting roadless areas. But what was most striking when reading through comments was what the arguments were built on. They speak about experiences in these places, shared across generations, and the impact they have had on people from all walks of life. They reflect heritage and traditions passed down through families and cultures. They hold a remarkable amount of hope and continued trust in a shared vision for the future of our planet. They value the common good over the profit of the few. They speak up for all life, not just human life. They trust in science. They revere beauty and something greater than ourselves.

We can also learn a great deal from comments in favor of opening up roadless areas. While some represent industry interests, many come from people with a deep connection to these lands. Some share the experiences of people with disabilities who are limited in how they can access public lands. Some point to communities, many of them Native, who rely on these lands for subsistence uses and rural economies. Others reflect the fears of communities increasingly impacted by wildfires. All of these voices should be welcomed and represented in decision-making for our public lands.

While it’s yet to be seen how these comments will be reflected in the fate of the Roadless Rule, they’ve provided an important opportunity for us to take a moment to listen to our neighbors and better understand our community.

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share by Mail
https://wildernesslandtrust.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Copy-of-Copy-of-banner-750-x-750-px.png 750 750 Margosia Jadkowski https://wildernesslandtrust.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/wilderness-land-trust-logo-2024.png Margosia Jadkowski2026-10-30 10:43:192026-10-30 10:43:19What we can learn from the Roadless Rule public comments

Join Us

Get more wilderness news delivered to your inbox!

Select list(s) to subscribe to


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: The Wilderness Land Trust, PO Box 881, Helena, MT, 59624, https://www.wildernesslandtrust.org. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Recent News

  • What we can learn from the Roadless Rule public comments
  • Catching up with an old friend: Old Woman Mountains Wilderness
  • Protecting a haven for endangered wildlife in Southern California
  • One step closer to wilderness for Snowmass Falls Ranch
  • What the Roadless Rule means for wilderness
61 acres, permanently protected. The Great Western 61 acres, permanently protected. The Great Western Lode and Needle Creek properties have been added to the Weminuche Wilderness, ensuring they’ll stay wild forever. When you give where you live through Colorado Gives day, your support fuels this work. Donate now through December 8th.
7,373 acres protected across Colorado and counting 7,373 acres protected across Colorado and counting! Give where you live, and help us continue to protect the wilderness you love this Colorado Gives Day. Early giving is now open through the link in our bio!
Over 1 million people participated in the public c Over 1 million people participated in the public comment period for the proposed rescission of the Roadless Area Conservation Rule, with 390,000 submissions and 81,000 unique comments.
 
We can learn a lot from them. We know that 97% of them opposed rescinding the Roadless Rule, and that the top topics mentioned in them were environmental protection and biodiversity; recreation, tourism, and public use; water quality and quantity; wildlife habitat; and forest management and wildfire.
 
But what was most striking when reading through comments was what the arguments were built on. They speak about experiences in these places, shared across generations, and the impact they have had on people from all walks of life. They reflect heritage and traditions passed down through families and cultures. They hold a remarkable amount of hope and continued trust in a shared vision for the future of our planet. They value the common good over the profit of the few. They speak up for all life, not just human life. They trust in science. They revere beauty and something greater than ourselves. 
 
We can also learn a great deal from comments in favor of opening up roadless areas. While some represent industry interests, many come from people with a deep connection to these lands. Some share the experiences of people with disabilities who are limited in how they can access public lands. Some point to communities, many of them Native, who rely on these lands for subsistence uses and rural economies. Others reflect the fears of communities increasingly impacted by wildfires. All of these voices should be welcomed and represented in decision-making for our public lands.
 
While it’s yet to be seen how these comments will be reflected in the fate of the Roadless Rule, they’ve provided an important opportunity for us to take a moment to listen to our neighbors and better understand our community.
We need your help to protect Robinson Creek! In We need your help to protect Robinson Creek!
 
In California’s Eastern Sierra, the Hoover Wilderness is a spectacular and rugged landscape of alpine lakes, blooming meadows, and granite spires and domes. The Robinson Creek property sits in its heart, overlooking to popular Robinson Creek Tail which leads hunters, anglers, and sportsmen in to the wilderness and neighboring Yosemite National Park. 
 
Your generous contribution will help us raise the remaining $21,750 needed to complete the project and protect the Robinson Creek property as wilderness. 

Donate today through the link in our bio.
With the Agua Blanca property now safeguarded from With the Agua Blanca property now safeguarded from development, we’re helping to protect watersheds and connected habitat for wildlife, and ensure future generations have the opportunity to experience wilderness solitude and inspiration.
A black bear joined Trust supporters in the Roarin A black bear joined Trust supporters in the Roaring Fork Valley of Colorado yesterday to hear about our work protecting local wilderness areas.
Follow on Instagram

Find us on Facebook!

X Logo X Logo Followon X
  • About
  • How We Work
  • News
  • Get Involved

THE WILDERNESS LAND TRUST
PO BOX 881
HELENA, MT 59624

PHONE: 206.397.5240

EIN 84-1192823

Stay Connected

Select list(s) to subscribe to


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: The Wilderness Land Trust, PO Box 881, Helena, MT, 59624, https://www.wildernesslandtrust.org. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact
© Copyright Wilderness Land Trust 2018
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
Link to: Catching up with an old friend: Old Woman Mountains Wilderness Link to: Catching up with an old friend: Old Woman Mountains Wilderness Catching up with an old friend: Old Woman Mountains Wilderness
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top
Give Now

Donate